Hello dear
Welcome To Emmy Squared Pizza: Midtown West, New York
Emmy Squared Pizza, located in Midtown West, New York, offers a delightful blend of culinary excellence and inviting ambiance. Renowned for their Detroit-style pizzas, the menu features crowd-pleasers like the Meatsiah Pizza, loaded with crispy Ezzo pepperoni and handcrafted Italian sausage, and the Mediterranean Steak & Olive Pizza, showcasing quality ingredients and rich flavors. The standout Le Big Matt burger, praised as the "Best Burger" in the US, further enhances the diverse offerings. Diners rave about the attentive service, particularly from staff like Kelly, ensuring a warm and welcoming experience in this cozy spot. Whether you're craving pizza or a hearty burger, Emmy Squared delivers remarkable taste in every bite.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Watermelon Burrata Salad
US$22.00Side Of Caramelized Onions
US$3.00Vodka Pizza
Kids Pizza Sticks
US$11.50Kids Chicken Bites
US$11.50Kids Burger
US$11.50Can Of Diet Coke*
US$4.00Can Of Sprite*
US$4.00Seasoned Waffle Fries
US$8.00 About
Emmy Squared Pizza: Midtown West, New York
Welcome to Emmy Squared Pizza, a delightful gem nestled in the vibrant Midtown West, New York. Located at 200 W 60th St, this pizzeria isn't just a stop for quick bites; it's a culinary experience that perfectly balances a welcoming atmosphere with a menu packed full of delectable offerings.
Emmy Squared is renowned for its Detroit-style pizza, characterized by its thick, rectangular slices that boast a crispy crust and generous toppings. But there's so much more on the menu that deserves your attention. Start off with their famous BKLYN Mozz Sticks, a dish featuring five hand-stretched mozzarella sticks served alongside their signature red sauce — pure cheesy bliss for just $17.50. For something a bit zestier, don’t miss the Jumbo Wings, offered in a variety of flavors, including a savory pineapple chili glaze and classic hot buffalo. These wings pack a punch and are perfect for sharing with friends.
Salad lovers will find comfort in the Brussels Sprouts Salad, combining pickled red onion, cashews, blue cheese, and dried cherries for a delightfully unique experience at $18.50. If you're after something more refreshing, try the Watermelon Burrata Salad, which seamlessly marries sweet and creamy elements.
No visit to Emmy Squared would be complete without indulging in their standout handhelds. The Le Big Matt, heralded as the "Best Burger in the US," features a half-pound doublestack of grass-fed beef, melted American cheese, and a special sauce served on a pretzel bun — a burger lover's paradise for $31.00. For blue cheese aficionados, the Le Bleu Burger is an unforgettable choice, expertly crafted with a blend of brisket and short rib.
The atmosphere here is as inviting as the food, with patrons frequently praising the attentive and friendly service. Take it from Yiyun Zheng, who raved about their fantastic vibe, or Marilena Kumbios, who found the gluten-free and vegan options exceptionally accommodating. It’s clear that Kelly, one of the standout servers, not only contributes to the restaurant’s warm ambiance but makes sure every guest leaves impressed.
In a city known for its pizzerias, Emmy Squared stands out not just for its pizza, but for its commitment to quality, service, and an overall unforgettable dining experience. Whether you're a pizza enthusiast or simply looking for a cozy spot to relax with friends, this Midtown West treasure is a must-visit. Prepare to be delighted — I know I was!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Came here w my entire friend group for some pizza, Kelly served our table and she’s the best! I love the vibes here and food is amazing!! ”
“ I found Emmy Squared Pizza on TikTok a few months ago and knew I had to try it! As I have recently started my vegan and gluten free diet, I have struggled with finding both accommodating pizzerias with both GF & Vegan options. I am from Staten Island, but I was in the city for a day and I had decided to finally stop by here for lunch! Kelly was a very attentive, friendly, and helpful waitress! I will definitely be coming back again next time I am in the city!! 10/10 recommend!! ”
“ This is rare for me. I legitimately have no complaints. The server Kelly was excellent! The food was fantastic, I am very happy I stopped in. Will be back! ”
“ Kelly was totally fabulous! Greeted us with a huge smile! Saw we needed a glass of water with our wine. Deciding on a bite...maybe breadsticks? Or? So much to choose from. Don’t hesitate to relax on the upper west side...cozy spot. ”
“ The smell of the pizza brought me here, but the wonderful service I instantly received from Kelly was even more inviting! She also made sure to explain the specials to me and the difference between the pizza styles so there was no confusion. I probably would have walked out normally because I wanted a different style of pizza, but Kelly made me want to stay and try the Detroit style pizza. Her wonderful energy and customer service will definitely cause me to come back. ”
“ I’m surprised they aren’t that busy because the service is fast and the food is really really food The watermelon salad is perfect for a hot summer NYC day and the Detroit pizzas are damn good! ”
“ So good!!! In town visiting friends, looking for good pizza. From Chicago, living in the Bay Area (which does have good pizza you just need to find it!), and this should be on your list to try. Detroit style can easily be too heavy, this was light, flavorful, and easy to get just one slice! The service was great and Kelly was so fun. Lots of seating, air conditioned, not cramped at all with no wait. Would for sure recommend! ”
“ We ended up there randomly walking. The dishwasher was broken so no dine in. They still let us order to go and eat outside at the tables. The MVP was literally the best pizza we ever had. We got a large, not regular which was a bit pricey 32 but my daughter and I ate all but three slices. It was fresh and the crust was crispy. The pesto sauce was amazing. We are so thankful to have stumbled in on this gem. ”